Safe Cities: Future Proofing

for Tomorrow and Beyond

The Safe Cities Index 2021

The Safe Cities Index, a global policy benchmarking tool launched by the Economist Intelligence Unit in 2015, marks its fourth iteration in 2021. Measuring urban safety across five domains—digital, health, infrastructure, personal and environmental security—using 76 indicators, each edition of the survey has been refined to reflect new concerns, such as covid-19. This year’s index has grown to cover 60 cities in Africa, the Americas, the Asia-Pacific, Europe and the Middle East, representing a variety of sizes, regions and income levels.

Future-proofing cities

Covid-19 is the first global pandemic since 2007, when the world became more urban than rural. The crisis has stretched cities’ resources, accelerated social and technological trends, and changed how we think about urban resilience.

To explore the urban security lessons that can be learned from covid-19, The Economist Group assembled an expert panel: Hans Jayatissa, chief technology officer at KMD; Esteban Léon, head of the City Resilience Global Programme at UN-Habitat; and Nicola Tollin, professor of urban resilience at the University of Southern Denmark (SDU).

The technology and flexibility to address global challenges

In addressing global challenges, governments must be flexible and use a holistic approach that anticipates multiple threats and considers the interconnected nature of complex urban systems. Ranking first in the Safe Cities Index 2021 is Copenhagen, and to focus their discussion, panellists examined what it and Denmark have done well, particularly in the past year.

Copenhagen has successfully used technology to fight covid-19 and climate change. To meet these and other global threats, cities need support from national governments, civil society and the private sector. To aid collective action, cities should share their data and expertise, particularly with peers in developing countries.

In its two most recent surveys, the United Nations ranked Denmark as the world leader in e-government. During the pandemic, the Danish government used the secure national digital post service to deliver information about covid-19 to all citizens. The country’s well-established telemedicine system was expanded to address social issues such as drug and alcohol abuse. A health app called “MinSundhed” or “MyHealth” was upgraded so people could receive covid-19 test results and demonstrate they had been vaccinated, and its user interface was enhanced to make it easier to navigate. Nicola Tollin of SDU attributes the utilisation of data in helping to monitor the spread of covid-19 to the trust held between civil society and the public administration.

Establishing effective cyber-security involves a delicate balance between protecting data and networks, and maintaining usability for people who may not have a technical background. Usability can be a particular concern for the elderly and people with disabilities. In Denmark, local organisations have offered training services so people could learn to access services without having to visit government offices during the pandemic. Copenhagen also focused on integrating its information technology systems to break down data silos and share health-care data more effectively.

In the public sector, digitalisation is often difficult. But in times of crisis, “this is really what distinguishes your city or your country from the rest,” observes Hans Jayatissa of KMD. Mr Tollin says Copenhagen benefited from a range of supporting factors, including public infrastructure such as open and green spaces, strong neighbourhoods with good services, access to fundamentals like free health-care and social services, and high trust in civil society. The city also kept contact with its most vulnerable groups, including ethnic minorities and the homeless.

Driving evidence-based decision-making

Data is a key to addressing global challenges such as climate change. For example, by using technology to measure the use of electricity, heat and water in government buildings, Copenhagen can better understand usage patterns, reduce consumption and increase efficiency. To do this, the data must drive what Esteban Léon of UN-Habitat calls “evidence-based decisions” at the political level.

While wealthy cities have the skills and technology to gather and exploit data, their peers in developing countries often lack resources. That represents an opportunity for cities like Copenhagen to share data, best practices and lessons learned, particularly with small- and medium-sized cities in the Global South.

Wherever they are, cities need support in the form of legislation, resources and capacity from national governments, civil society and the private sector. As Nicola Tollin notes, urban safety “should be a common effort, a common responsibility.”

The need for a new mindset

Climate change and similarly serious threats require a new mindset, because they are global in scope but require local action. That calls for effective communication and collaboration among supranational organisations, as well as between national, regional and local governments. At each of these levels, organisations need to be flexible so they can react quickly to changes in the environment.

“We need to understand that we need some radical changes in the ways in which we consume and we produce. These radical changes, unfortunately, are not going to be easy”. Nicola Tollin

In addition to making a co-operative effort, leaders must embrace systems-based thinking. Complex urban systems are interconnected and require a “multi-hazard, multi-sectoral and multi-stakeholder approach”, says Mr Léon. “We should not forget about the important things because we are reacting to the urgent things.”


Copyright © 2021
The Economist Group. All rights reserved. Neither this publication nor any part of it may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without prior permission of The Economist Group. Whilst every effort has been taken to verify the accuracy of information presented at this conference, neither The Economist Group nor its affiliates can accept any responsibility or liability for reliance by any person on this information.

The Economist Events
The Economist Events is a part of The Economist Group, publisher of The Economist newspaper. Sharing The Economist’s commitment to informed, impartial and independent debate, we are recognised the world over as a leading provider of highly interactive meetings—including industry conferences, private gatherings and government roundtables—for senior executives seeking new insights into important strategic issues. 1301, 13/F 12 Taikoo Wan Road, Taikoo Shing, Hong Kong Web www.economistevents.com • Phone +852 2585 3821

Download PDF

Urban Safety Benchmarking Tool

VS

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

Fill in the form to use the Urban Benchmarking Tool

This privacy notice aims to give you information on how NEC Corporation collects and processes your personal data when you download or use the following contents. - Safe Cities Index white paper - Safe Cities Index data book - Safe Cities Index city comparison tool 1. Controller of the Personal Data (1) Company name : NEC Corporation (hereinafter referred to as "NEC") (2) Contact details : General Manager, Integrated Marketing Communication Division, NEC Corporation to cont_strategy@imc.jp.nec.com  (3) Postal address : 7-1, Shiba 5-chome, Minato-ku, Tokyo Japan 108-8001 2. Categories of the Personal Data Personal data includes name, e-mail address, company name and a result of city comparison tool if you use. 3. Purposes of Processing for the Personal Data (1) To respond to inquiries. (2) To respond to requests (3) To introduce or relay information about companies (NEC Group Companies) that deal with NEC products, services, and solutions. (4) To provide information or publicity materials about NEC products, services, and solutions. (5) To provide information about events such as seminars and exhibitions. (6) To contact customers. 4. Recipients of the Personal Data NEC, NEC Group companies, their distributors and agents, NEC affiliates throughout the world, and companies that operate and manage NEC's inquiry site in Japan, upon the assurance that sufficient safety control measures have been established, which have concluded agreements concerning the processing of personal data, to provide services to their customers, within the scope of the stated purposes for using personal data. 5. Overseas Transfer of the Personal Data Economist Intelligence Unit manages and operates this website. (1) Information transfer to a third country: Upon receipt of your inquiry, your personal data will be sent to Hong Kong & Japan. (2) Question of adequate protection: The European Commission has recognized Japan as providing adequate protection of personal data. 6. Period for Which the Personal Data Will Be Stored Personal data may be stored for as long as necessary to achieve the stated purpose for using it. 7. Rights of the Data Subject Under certain circumstances, you have the right with regard to the personal data which you provide as follows: - The right to request from the controller access to and rectification or erasure of personal data or restriction of processing concerning the data subject - The right to object to processing concerning the data subject - The right to data portability: The right to receive the personal data, which the data subject has provided to a data controller, in a structured, commonly used and machine-readable format, and to transmit those data to another data controller without hindrance from the controller to which the personal data have been provided (NEC) - The right to withdraw consent at any time, without affecting the lawfulness of processing based on consent before its withdrawal - The right to lodge a complaint with a supervisory authority, if it exists, in the country or region that the data object belongs 8. Statutory or Contractual Requirement Concerning the Provision of the Personal Data Provision of the personal data is not a statutory or contractual requirement, or a requirement necessary to enter into a contract, and you are not obliged to provide personal data. However, if you choose not to provide personal data, it may not be possible to respond to some inquiries. 9. Non-existence of Decision-making Based Solely on Automated Processing The access log for this website undergoes analysis, however, we do not make decisions that might affect you based solely on automated processing of the personal data that you provide, including profiling, in order to analyze or predict your likes and dislikes or personal behavior. 10. Parental Consent If you are under the age of 18, please make your participation in the survey ONLY AFTER obtaining consent given or authorized by the holder of parental responsibility over you. 11. Encrypted Communication The survey form on this page uses encrypted communication via Secure Socket Layer (SSL) for personal data protection. 12. Security of Processing the Personal Data Recipients of the personal data implement appropriate technical and organisational measures to ensure a level of security appropriate to the risk.

Select Cities to Compare

You can benchmark your city to any of the 60 cities in the index by answering 12 questions about safety. Your answers will be compared to the selected city and will allow you to get an idea of how the cities compare.

Answer the questions about

Does the city have a smart city plan that explicitly focuses on the cybersecurity of the smart city?

Answer the questions about

What percentage of the city’s population has access to the internet?

%

Answer the questions about

How many doctors (per 1,000 population) does the city have?

Answer the questions about

What is the average life expectancy of the population in the city?

Answer the questions about

What is the covid-19 mortality rate (per 100,000 population) in the city?

Answer the questions about

Does the city have a disaster emergency management / city business continuity plan in place and, if so, how adaptive and effective is it?

Answer the questions about

Is disaster risk included and accounted for in active state- or city-level urban planning and design?

Answer the questions about

What percentage of GDP is spent on social assistance programs?

%

Answer the questions about

How prevalent is violent crime in the city?

Answer the questions about

Does the city masterplan outline specific measures for sustainable growth of the urban centre?

Answer the questions about

What is the average annual concentration of PM 2.5 in µg/m3?

Answer the questions about

What is the percentage of tree cover within the city?

%

Calculating Scores...

0%

Urban Safety Benchmarking Tool

Comparison Results

0

out of 24 (full score)

LOWER THAN BENCHMARK CITY

CRITERIA

Does the city have a smart city plan that explicitly focuses on the cybersecurity of the smart city

What percentage of the city’s population has access to the internet

How many doctors (per 1,000 population) does the city have

What is the average life expectancy of the population in the city

What is the covid-19 mortality rate (per 100,000 population) in the city

Does the city have a disaster emergency management / city business continuity plan in place and, if so, how adaptive and effective is it

Is disaster risk included and accounted for in active state- or city-level urban planning and design

What percentage of GDP is spent on social assistance programs

How prevalent is violent crime in the city

Does the city masterplan outline specific measures for sustainable growth of the urban centre

What is the average annual concentration of PM 2.5 in µg/m3

7

What is the percentage of tree cover within the city

Fill in the form to
download the file

NEC Safer Cities Report

Population growth and urbanisation promote development and create value, but also bring about new risks. Learn how NEC is creating cities that are safe, secure, fair and efficient.

FIND OUT MORE
NEC Safer Cities

NEC’s technology solutions for creating safer cities cover the key areas of public safety, smart transportation, digital government, city management and digital health care.

FIND OUT MORE
NEC insights

Read news and case studies about how NEC technology is helping to build smarter, safer cities and intelligent business solutions that solve industrial and social challenges.

FIND OUT MORE